Mutual Fund Perfection
It’s may come as a surprise to you that the mutual fund industry, at least in the United States, is a shining record of fiduciary duty. It’s a fact that not once in twenty-five years did a shareholder in one of these funds manage to convince a court that their money has, in any way whatsoever, been mismanaged. This is despite a raft of allegations, originally stemming from the investigations of the ever-vigilant, if nocturnally over-enthusiastic, ex-Attorney General of New York, Elliot Spitzer, that many of the advisors running these funds had deliberately siphoned profits from long-term individual shareholders to institutional clients.
However, a recent judicial decision moves the goalposts – it’s no longer theoretically impossible for a private shareholder to successfully sue a mutual fund. No, now it’s actually impossible. The reason for this is grounded in an economic theory of the marketplace that is dying everywhere else: the idea that markets are perfect. It’s time for a little behavioural law and order.
It’s may come as a surprise to you that the mutual fund industry, at least in the United States, is a shining record of fiduciary duty. It’s a fact that not once in twenty-five years did a shareholder in one of these funds manage to convince a court that their money has, in any way whatsoever, been mismanaged. This is despite a raft of allegations, originally stemming from the investigations of the ever-vigilant, if nocturnally over-enthusiastic, ex-Attorney General of New York, Elliot Spitzer, that many of the advisors running these funds had deliberately siphoned profits from long-term individual shareholders to institutional clients.
However, a recent judicial decision moves the goalposts – it’s no longer theoretically impossible for a private shareholder to successfully sue a mutual fund. No, now it’s actually impossible. The reason for this is grounded in an economic theory of the marketplace that is dying everywhere else: the idea that markets are perfect. It’s time for a little behavioural law and order.